| Year | POY -COY | 1st Team | 2nd Team | SHM | HM |
| 2000 | Garrett Morrison -DB | ||||
| 2001 |
Derek Nelson - OL Jarrett Baisden - OL Jamie Berry -RB Aaron Meckstroth - UTL Gifford Perdue -DL |
||||
| 2002 | Nate Howard - OL | ||||
| 2003 | |||||
| 2004 |
Clay Maddox - UTL Corey Adkins - OL |
||||
| 2005 | |||||
| 2006 | Keebie Gilkerson - LB | ||||
| 2007 | Keebie Gilkerson - LB | ||||
| 2008 | George Brody -K |
Evan Thacker Joey McComas |
Kevin Lawrence John Fry Zach Wellman Dane Niday |
Zach Harrison Seth Morris |
|
| 2009 |
Brad Dingess - COY Conference Runner-Up |
George Brody -K Evan Thacker - OT John Fry - DL Zach Wellman - LB Dane Niday - UTL |
|||
| 2010 |
Elijah Wellman - LB Anthony Evans - UTL |
||||
| 2011 |
Elijah Wellman -LB Matt Jones -OT Sean Hayton - K |
||||
| 2012 |
Elijah Wellman - LB Trevor Stacy - OT |
||||
| 2013 |
Trevor Stacy -OT Alex Locklear - OT |
||||
| 2014 | Trevor Stacy - OT | ||||
| 2015 |
Skylar Larcart - G Jonah Wellman - LB Logan Wilcox - DB |
||||
| 2016 |
Brad Dingess - COY Conference Champions |
Jonah Wellman - LB Owen Porter -UTL Caiden Conley - DL Riley Locklear - OT Doug Nester -G Mason Brubeck -RB Derek Johnson - QB |
|||
| 2017 | Conference Runner-Up |
Jacob Cassidy -TE Owen Porter - LB Graeson Malashevich - UTL DOug Nester - G |
|||
| 2018 |
Graeson Malashevich -POY Brad Dingess - COY Conference Champions |
Doug Nester -G Hunter Bellomy - LB Cody Stanley - DL |
Owen Chaffin Jake Hutchison Zach WIlliamson Wyatt Milum Parker Elmore David Livingston |
Isaac Howard Tyson Hall Cody Sharp |
Luke Jarrell Zane Porter |
| 2019 | COnference Runner-Up |
Jake Hutchison - C Wyatt Milum - OT Zane Porter -K Luke Christopher - LB David Livingston - DB Brody Brumfield - DB |
Corbin Page Zane Brumfield Clayton Sharp |
Nate Ellis |
Garrett Hall Cole Diamond |
| 2020 |
Wyatt Milum Cole Diamond Corbin Page Brody Brumfield |
||||
| 2021 |
Ty Bartrum - POY Conference Runner-Up |
Corbin Page -TE Dalton Fouch -QB Cody Shy - LB Jace Caldwell - DB |
Ben Turner Shane Roberts Matthew Hall |
Cole Petry Conner McCann Kyndon Keesee |
Brin Booth Dalton Caldwell |
| 2022 |
Sam Booth -OL Jalyn AbercrombieUTL Conner McCann - DL Cody Shy - LB Kyrell Lewis - DB Landon Mosser- P |
Trey Wahl Isaiah Dotson Kyndon Kessee |
Dalton Fouch Shane Roberts |
Bruin Booth Cam Bailey |
|
| 2023 |
Jalyn AbercrombieUTL Brae Booth -DL Sam Booth - LB |
Cole Ferguson Mikey Shy Bryce Fuller Garrett Wagoner |
Braydon Casto Tucker Hammond Logan Harris |
Tate Adkins Liam McGuire |
|
| 2024 |
Jalyn Abercrombie - WR Brayden Casto - OL Braxton Carter - OL Tristan Watts - DL Cam Perdue - LB Logan Harris - DB |
Liam McGuire Miguel Cain Brae Booth Dylan Robertson Garret Wagoner |
Cole Ferguson Bryce Fuller |
||
